IVI Framework Viewer

Business Case Creation

A4

Create and review business cases for evaluating sourcing options for IT services.

Improvement Planning

Practices-Outcomes-Metrics (POM)

Representative POMs are described for Business Case Creation at each level of maturity.

1Initial
  • Practice
    Rely on the best endeavours of available personnel.
2Basic
  • Practice
    Develop cost-focused business cases for significant providers to large projects.
    Outcome
    Significant provider partnerships have basic business cases that include high-level, cost-benefit analyses.
    Metric
    # of factors considered in business cases.
  • Practice
    Undertake some baseline assessment and forecasting whilst acknowledging it may not be accurately quantified.
    Outcome
    A basic understanding of current service performance is gained.
    Metric
    Service performance metrics.
3Intermediate
  • Practice
    Develop the business cases as part of the process for evaluating Sourcing options that cover all key strategic objectives and factors, not just cost.
    Outcome
    Sourcing decisions can be assessed and compared objectively against multiple important business factors.
    Metric
    % of Sourcing decisions based on business cases.
  • Practice
    Develop a business case that includes a quantified baseline of current service performance, cost, etc.
    Outcome
    There is an accurate understanding of current service performance and cost, etc. meaning that the business case is driven by accurate, quality data.
    Metric
    # of iterations performed to check quality of input data.
4Advanced
  • Practice
    Establish a value-based business case (linkage to business outcomes) and a development and assessment process as part of the Sourcing decision-making process.
    Outcome
    All Sourcing decisions are supported by robust, consistent, data-driven business cases.
    Metric
    % of Sourcing decisions that are not based on a business case calculation.
  • Practice
    Capture a standardized baseline of current service performance and cost for use in forecasting future requirements and business case development.
    Outcome
    Business cases are based on current service performance informing decisions.
    Metric
    % and # of business cases with standardized baseline of current service performance specified.
5Optimized
  • Practice
    Regularly review and update business cases and amend the templates to improve their effectiveness.
    Outcome
    Business cases are permanently up-to-date and can serve as an ongoing decision basis.
    Metric
    % of Sourcing business case realizations arising from business case reviews.
  • Practice
    Regularly measure and assess service delivery against original business case objectives and feed the results into the Sourcing re-evaluation process.
    Outcome
    The interface to re­evaluation is smooth.
    Metric
    # of re-evaluations of business cases.