IVI Framework Viewer

Provider Selection

B1

Ensure that the approach used for selecting IT service providers adheres to and influences the organization's procurement procedures.

Improvement Planning

Practices-Outcomes-Metrics (POM)

Representative POMs are described for Provider Selection at each level of maturity.

1Initial
  • Practice
    Rely on the best endeavours of available personnel.
2Basic
  • Practice
    Send a Request for Information (RFI) to potential providers.
    Outcome
    There is an overview of potential providers aiding the selection process.
    Metric
    # of process steps within provider selection.
  • Practice
    Undertake the provider selection process using a consistent process within IT.
    Outcome
    All providers are selected fairly using a consistent process within IT.
    Metric
    % of providers selected in cooperation with corporate procurement.
3Intermediate
  • Practice
    Establish a detailed process including an initial list of candidates, RFIs, short list, RFPs, and final selection.
    Outcome
    Provider selection follows a standard process that can be reproduced.
    Metric
    # of process steps within provider selection.
  • Practice
    Ensure provider selection processes and criteria involve input from the procurement function.
    Outcome
    The IT function selection process involves procurement and is in alignment with the organization process.
    Metric
    % of providers selected in co-operation with corporate procurement
4Advanced
  • Practices
    • Distinguish between a first-time bid and a renewal bidding process.
    • Selection criteria reflect the corporate business strategy and include a cultural fit assessment.
    Outcome
    Provider selection in a renewal of a Sourcing contract takes into account that the incumbent has a much deeper knowledge.
    Metric
    # of process steps being adjusted for a renewal.
  • Practice
    Fully integrate provider selection in the organization-wide procurement process.
    Outcome
    Selected providers fit both in terms of performance but also in terms of cultural fit.
    Metrics
    • # of provider landscape analyses conducted organization-wide.
    • % of selected providers fitting in with the company culture aspect.
5Optimized
  • Practice
    Evaluate the provider's business case during the process of selecting the optimal provider.
    Outcome
    The provider has a realistic opportunity to deliver on a timely and reliable basis.
    Metric
    % of selected providers realizing their business cases that are evaluated.
  • Practice
    Continually review and optimize the provider selection process and criteria, and their interaction with the organization-wide procurement process.
    Outcome
    Realized synergies can be optimized.
    Metrics
    • # of joint meetings with procurement.
    • # of synergies realized.
    • % of actions completed arising from a review of strategic Sourcing aspects of the provider selection process.